I think I like three guys, that possibly like me back…

First Guy: He’s a tall brunette with an incredible sense of humor, but we barely ever hangout and he can never find the time to fit me in.
Positives:
Tells me everything
is very very attractive
His parents love me (adds to it)
Dated him once
We can talk about anything and I’m the only thing that matters to him in the end.
He doesn’t bother me with a million texts
He’s a hockey player (On my brothers team though…)
He never wants to let me go when we hug
Negatives:
He’s a bad kisser (He goes very slow, but maybe it’s just me)
He never gets jealous (maybe he doesn’t like me)
He can be very immature most times

Second Guy: Tall blond hockey player who I’ve been friends with since Grade 6 He is very charming and teases me a lot, but flirty.
Positives:
Most handsome guy I know… so hot ha ha
He’s very good at hockey and plays in the city, even though we live in a small town and he drives me to his games to watch
I’m friends with both his sisters
I’ve slept over with his sisters ha ha (not much of a positive, but I saw him shirtless at the time)
He tells me I’m beautiful not hot, it makes my day
He is the best cuddler
When we watch movies we don’t actually watch them, I’m focused on him
He will do anything with me just to make me happy
We know everything about each other
He never ignores me
He’d rather hangout with me than his team
He’s the first person I text in the morning and last person I text at night
We plan lunches together
We’ve dated twice
Negatives:
He is my bestfriend, I’d die if I lost him
He’s immature (like all three)
He doesn’t tell me what’s on his mind
He never makes the first move
When he doesn’t like me, he likes my best friend/teammate (but she’s never liked him)

Third Guy: He’s a tall very muscular athlete, brunette. He’s that kind of stereotypical jock of the school with all the set records. He loves to write, he takes singing lessons and we’ve known each other since Kindergarten.
Positives:
VERY attractive
The only songs he’s written are about me
He’s writing a story and I’ve read it and the description is very close to me (Love story too)
Charming, Always makes the first move.
He gets jealous… hot jealous.
He’d make sure I was okay and the person who made me feel this way isn’t.
He’s sensitive, cute sensitive.
Dated him three times
Negatives:
He can be a real jerk sometimes (he’s violated me grabbing my a** deserving a slap)
He can change his mind a lot about who he likes,
We USED to have long conversations until I dated someone he didn’t like.
He hits on every other girl (Maybe hes every ones guy… not going to share)
VERY immature at times
We’re not friends when he doesn’t like me.

I NEED HELP…. which guy and why’ Just your advice. and your decision
Could I love one of them’
THIS IS NOT A BISEXUAL GAY LESBIAN SUBJECT….I didn’t notice the category lol